You wouldn't believe such an interesting creature existed until you saw it with your own eyes.
この場合、次のような言い方ができますよ。
ーYou wouldn't believe such an interesting creature existed until you saw it with your own eyes.
「あんな面白い生き物が存在していたなんて、実際に自分の目で見ないと信じないだろう」
You wouldn't believe ... until you saw it with your own eyes. で「自分の目で見るまで…だと信じないだろう」と言えます。
ご参考まで!